Why Hotels Should Think Twice About Switching to Dispensers
In the pursuit of sustainability and cost-efficiency, many hotels are considering switching from traditional single-use toiletry bottles to bulk dispensers. While the transition may seem like a logical step at first glance, especially with the promise of reduced plastic waste, the financial and guest satisfaction implications are often oversimplified. Let’s unpack why the cost savings aren’t as straightforward as advertised and explore why guests may not always welcome the change.
The Hidden Costs of Dispensers
Dispenser systems are often marketed as a cost-saving measure, but the reality can be quite different. Here’s a breakdown of typical annual costs:
- Dispenser Systems with Cartridge Replacements: $17,250
- Single-Use Toiletry Bottles: $14,400
At first glance, the $2,850 difference might seem small, but it adds up over time, especially for small to medium-sized properties working with tight budgets. Why are dispensers more expensive?
-
Cartridge Costs: Unlike single-use bottles, dispensers require cartridges that are often proprietary, locking you into long-term vendor contracts. The per-unit cost of these cartridges can be significantly higher than bulk purchases of traditional bottles.
-
Installation and Maintenance: Dispensers require installation, which might mean hiring professionals to ensure they are securely and hygienically mounted. Ongoing maintenance, such as cleaning and unclogging dispensers or replacing damaged units, further adds to the expense.
-
Wastage: Guests may overuse products in dispensers compared to the controlled portioning of single-use bottles. Additionally, improperly functioning dispensers can leak, wasting product.
What Guests Think About Dispensers
While sustainability is a key motivator for many hotels, guest preferences remain a critical factor in maintaining satisfaction and loyalty. Unfortunately, dispensers often face resistance from guests for several reasons:
-
Hygiene Concerns: Many guests worry about the cleanliness of shared dispensers, questioning whether they have been properly cleaned or if previous users have tampered with them.
-
Perceived Luxury: Single-use bottles have long been associated with indulgence and pampering. Swapping these out for dispensers can make some guests feel like they are receiving a less luxurious experience, which may impact overall satisfaction.
-
Product Quality Doubts: Dispensers often lack branding, making guests skeptical about the quality of the products inside. Guests may feel more reassured when they see recognizable, trusted brands on single-use bottles.
-
Practicality Issues: Dispensers aren’t always user-friendly. For example, if a guest has mobility issues or if the dispenser is mounted awkwardly, it can be difficult to use.
-
Refill Neglect: Nothing frustrates a guest more than finding an empty dispenser mid-shower. While single-use bottles provide a visible stock level, dispensers can be overlooked by housekeeping staff.
Balancing Sustainability and Guest Experience
The switch to dispensers is often presented as a sustainability triumph, but there are alternative ways to reduce environmental impact without compromising guest satisfaction. For example:
- Opt for single-use bottles made from recycled or biodegradable materials.
- Partner with suppliers that offer refillable single-use options to minimize waste while maintaining luxury.
- Encourage guests to take unused toiletries home, turning them into ambassadors for your brand rather than waste.
Conclusion
While the intention behind switching to dispensers is commendable, the financial and experiential trade-offs need careful consideration. Hotels must weigh the higher costs and potential guest dissatisfaction against the environmental benefits. Ultimately, finding a solution that aligns with both sustainability goals and guest expectations will deliver the best results.
Your guests expect comfort, cleanliness, and care—make sure your toiletry choices reflect those values.